Business Directory

Browse the Directory

Sign Up to the Directory

FC Business Twitter
FC business Linked in
FC Business facebook
FC Business Youtube

Crystal Palace Win Employment Legal Case

Wed 13th Nov 2013 | Legal

Sports lawyers at Walker Morris have won a major employment legal case in the Court of Appeal for Crystal Palace FC.

The judgment reinforces the original decision of the Employment Tribunal and provides an important clarification in relation to employment law and in particular TUPE.

The case centred on the dismissal of a number of employees of Crystal Palace FC back in May 2010 at a time when the club was in administration and facing serious financial difficulty with administrator, Brendan Guilfoyle, attempting to sell the club as a going concern. 

With the serious prospect of liquidation, the decision was taken to run the club with a skeleton staff in the hope that a sale could be made.   As a result Lisa Kavanagh, Kevin Watts, Elizabeth Roake and David Moss and 25 others were dismissed.

A sale was made to CPFC Limited (with Walker Morris as their advisors) and the Club went on to enjoy success both on and off the pitch starting the 2013-2014 football season in the Premier League for the first time since the 2004-2005 season.

The case concerned whether the four employees were dismissed in such a manner that the TUPE Regulations (Transfer of Undertaking Regulations 2006) which protects employees' continuity of employment and terms and conditions, were transferred to the purchaser, or alternatively whether this was not the case as the dismissals were as a result of economic, technical or organisational reasons.  

It was held that the dismissals were made as a result of economic, technical or organisational reasons due to the fact that the administrator did not have sufficient funds to pay the employees without making such dismissals.

David Hinchliffe, Head of the Sports Group at Walker Morris said: "We are delighted with the outcome which confirms that even though the dismissals were connected with the transfer the purchaser did not pick up the liabilities as the dismissals were for economic and organisational reasons.

"This is a major case and will clarify the circumstances in which a company in administration may dismiss staff without incurring a liability for unfair dismissal.  The case should have a positive impact on the rescue culture." 


 Posted by: Aaron Gourley

To subscribe to our range of football newsletters including news, products and jobs CLICK HERE.




If you have any football business related news stories you’d like to share then please contact us – agourley@fcbusiness.co.uk

Add to: Google Google | Yahoo Yahoo | Live Live | del.icio.us del.icio | Digg Digg |

Related Articles

Premier League Clubs Gather To Tackle Counterfeiters

Mon 25th Sep 2017 | Legal

Premier League clubs gathered at the Etihad Stadium last week to highlight the significant anti-counterfeiting programme now run across the League. The Premier League Anti-Counterfeiting Programme...

Supreme Court Rules Against Rangers in 'Big Tax Case'

Wed 5th Jul 2017 | Legal

The Supreme Court has ruled in favour of HMRC over Rangers’ use of Employee Benefit Trusts (EBTs) between 2001 and 2010. In its judgement over the use of EBTs, the Supreme Court upheld...

Legal Comment: Football’s Deep Filled Problem With Gambling

Fri 24th Feb 2017 | Legal

On 20 February 2016, the FA Cup fixture between Sutton United and Arsenal turned into a media frenzy and one to remember, for all the wrong reasons. Laura McCallum, solicitor at Harper Macleod...

Manchester City Charged Over Anti-Doping Rule Breaches

Thu 12th Jan 2017 | Legal

The Football Association (The FA) have charged Manchester City for failing to ensure anti-doping officials knew where players were for drugs testing. Manchester City have been charged for failing to...